Multiple Scenes for same device

Configuration
1

I’ve got a smart bulb that I want to create automatons for.

Basically, I want the light to be red if turned on between 10PM and 6AM and Yellow between 6AM and 10PM.
I’ve got the automation built using scenes

My problem is with creating the “Day Scene” (Yellow) and “Night Scene” (red)
When I create the Yellow scene, it saves fine. When I create the “Red” one it saves but the Yellow one becomes Red… It happens regardless of which I create first

I’ve tried creating one, restarting HA and then creating the next but, I get the same results

2

Don’t create a scene, just set the light color in call service light turn on

Day is X color and night is Y color, you can set them any way you want this way.

3

There are plenty of use cases where you want the same device to have different values that are applied by a scene. Scenes also have the advantage that you can add or remove things from the scene, or change their settings without having to touch the automation.

I have a smart switch that with a normal press, turns some lights on and off, but if I long press the switch, the same light is dimmed. I’ve never had an issue with having multiple scenes reference the same device.

So perhaps the issue is with your automation that selects the scene ?