Very basic automation not working

Configuration
1

Hey guys,

Hoping someone can shed some light here as I feel I am going crazy. I have 2 Lutron Pico remotes that I want to use to control my outside Hue bulbs. One will be my porch lights and the other will be the house lights. I went in and added an automation on Pico 1, where when "On" is pressed, it turns the 3 porch lights on, and when the "off is pressed it turns them off. However after setting up the automation and testing it, it doesnt work. The On works, however the Off does nothing. This is my only automation so far as I am just setting up my new house. Does anyone have any ideas? I've re-created it probably 10 times so far and I get the same result every time.

Couple things to note -

I moved my eero over from my previous house, so for the Hue hub, I simply plugged it back into my router and everything carried over from the old house

I initially had my Home Assisitant Green on my upstairs eero and the Lutron hub on the basement eero. When adding the hub, it couldnt find it, so I moved it upstairs to the same eero with the HA and it found it and added all my devices.

In the Hue app, the house lights and porch lights were initially under the same group of "Outside lights", which I broke up into "Porch" and "House" during troubleshooting. I also moved the Hue hub to the same eero as my HA.

Anyone have any ideas? This is a very basic automation, not sure why it isnt working

Thanks

2

If you can turn them on, then you hardware and network setup is fine.

You might have made an error in the automation.
Can you post the YAML and please format it correctly or we will loose important informations.

Bullet 11 here: How to help us help you - or How to ask a good question

3

Is this what youre looking for? Came home from work and neither the on or off work now. Weird note, when I was at work I had my wife test it and everything worked

alias: Porch On
description: ''
triggers:
  - device_id: d80649e50d4c96efed8dc342a680f34d
    domain: lutron_caseta
    type: press
    subtype: 'on'
    trigger: device
conditions: []
actions:
  - action: light.turn_on
    metadata: {}
    target:
      entity_id:
        - light.outside_lights_porch_1
        - light.outside_lights_porch_2
        - light.outside_lights_porch_3
    data: {}
mode: single