So… the HA team shouldn’t have released their “fix” (nothing in HA was technically broken) to protect against the possible “exploit” and instead, waited for the third party applications, that may have been unscrupulously extracting data about your home on purpose, to remove that behavior from their code?
No. you misunderstood me or I havent written it down in a proper way (English is not my native tongue).
Let me try again. I dont want my message to be misinterpreted.
First of all: I appreciate it a lot (hence the thank you) that the devs of Home Assistant fixed the issue on the home assistant side and that they did inform us that there is a possible issue outside home assistant. I did not say or intended to say that they shouldn’t have. On the contrary I thank them.
What I meanth is that I would understand that currently they don’t fully explain what custom integration could be causing a possible risk. That’s what I meant with the ‘strategy’. I assumed that if there is an external developer in good faith who wants to fix the issue in custom integration. And that they need some time to fix it. With the immediate treath being stopped there is some time to wait with providing information untill the external software had the opportunity to fix it. And make sure the root cause also is fixed.
Like it is done in cases of data breaches that where possible; explain what happened after it’s fixed to prevent others using the exploit.
I’d love to hear it, because as a newer user I can learn what makes my system vulnerable.
Okay, I understand not everyone can understand these things but sometimes it’s best to assume we are in good hands and be patient: The fix (filter) is in release .3 that everyone was advised to upgrade to. Regardless of how many, if any, active inappropriateness was out there, HA will now block and log the activity, and we all are reminded that custom code, carries a risk that the HA team cannot be liable for.
Wow. Since you reply to my message I feel you see me as a person without trust and patience. I just hope my explanation above helped to make my point. Because the way you describe me as not understanding shows there is incorrect. I have patience and trust. I dont have any demands (only things i would love to see) and am very gratefull to be able to use open source software other wrote in their spare time.
For everyone that works on HA, thank you for all that you do.
And also in that… we find agreement