WTH are all Automations not state ful/persistent. Now my lights, garden pump, electic radiator no longer switched off after a reboot

Your automation’s design appears to have been based on ideal operating conditions and overlooked to mitigate failure scenarios such as:

  • the controlled device becomes unavailable
  • the transmitted command isn’t received
  • there’s a restart while the automation is executing its actions
  • there’s a restart when a Time Trigger was supposed to fire

Your suggestion to automatically resume from wherever it was interrupted isn’t optimal; the conditions that originally triggered the automation may no longer be applicable after a restart.

You will have better control by simply adding a trigger to the automation that detects a restart and then proceeds to handle the situation appropriately. I have several critical automations that use this technique to make them more fault-tolerant.

The following (old) post offers a few ideas on how to mae an automation more robust.

1 Like