2-3 gang tuya relay switch with single controler delays

Hardware
1

Hi.
I need some advice on best 2-3 gang Zigbee switches or relay modules working with ZHA.
I have some 2 and 3 gang Zigbee Tuya switches modules. in ZHA they are shown as TS0012/TS0013 and work as expected … almost.
The problem is that when I try to switch 2-3 gangs at close to same time only one action works. This means that from 3 buttons I pres in ~1 second time, only one light is switched. If I press buttons - one each second, there is not problem.
In the same time I have some MOES New Star Ring Tuya Smart ZigBee3.0 Button Switches - again 2 and 3 gang - happen to be again TS0012/TS0013 and again the same problem

On the other hand I have some old Aqara C1 2 gang No-Neutral switches and Aqara 2 gang with Neutral relays that works super fast - you can press buttons one after another with no delay at all - but devices are not made for EU and are harder to install.

I guess my question is - is this problem known ? Which switches/relays does not have this delays between controls of different channels like the old Aqara devices ?

Thanks for the help

1 Like
2

It is strange that no one saw this problem before - it is really annoying.
Can someone tell me if this is specific to Tuya based switches or no?
I was hoping to have some advice on what hardware to depend on in the future ?

3

I only have tested the tuya zigbee switches & the relay wifi version and both does pick up simultaneous button press.

4

@ferbulous can you share which tuya zigbee switches have you tested - are they new model or older ones ?

5

I have the same problem with 2 gang relay. Bought on Ali
https://www.aliexpress.com/item/1005003527612636.html

6

I’m having the exact same issue here, any update on this? I’m not using the capacitor (but it works except for this simultaneous issue), maybe it’s for not using it?

1 Like
7

Hi, I have same problem.

I’m using zha TS0012 with version 0x00000044. When I connected wires (before integrating with HA) I tested physical switches and when I change state for both at the same time only one is registered (I think it’s always second). When I clicked them separatelly then both works fine

8

Hi, I have exactly the same problem.

If someone have found a solution :slight_smile:

9

Same here. Same problem

Whenever I try to physically switch 2 relays at the same time (from the same box), only one will work.

have this issue with 2 gang AND 3 gang, multiple manufacturers. both Zigbee and wifi.

if I provide a small delay between clicks, it works.