I spent some time googling this issue specifically with hue bulbs, rather than with Home Assistant and it’s been reported before. I found out there’s a setting in the hue app to “clean” the hue bridge. Tried that, we’ll see if anything changes tomorrow.
To be honest I have no idea what the problem was. I ended up wiping and resetting my hue bridge and my lutron bridge, and added everything back. My issue was fixed after that. Nuclear option was my last resort.