I do not have any experience with any of these brands or smart meter so hoping if others can share their experiences specific to any of the meters listed here.
Thanks.
PS: Also I use WiFi for all my IoTs so do not have any Zigbee or Z hub.
I just purchased the Rainforest EAGLE-200 and it works well with PG&E energy, and supports hardwired/wifi connectivity to home network.
Setup was smooth, connection from SmartMeter to device was initiated from PG&E website and took a few minutes, the PG&E SmartMeter is ~40 feet away vertically and ~20 feet horizontally, so ~44 ft across multiple floors and into the garage.
Integration was auto discovered in HA, but both were on the same subnet; I have no idea whether it will talk well across subnets - but I will find out soon (I don’t intend to update this comment, though).
Once configured in HA, you receive 1 device with 3 sensors:
Demand (kw consumption at this instant)
updated at 30 second interval
Total Delivered (kw/h you receive from energy company, i.e. delivered from PG&E to you)
updated at 4 minute interval - may depend on power consumption rate
total across lifetime I guess, same value that the meter shows when you face it in person
Total Received (kw/h you provide to the energy company, i.e. received by PG&E from you)
updated at 4 minute interval - may depend on power consumption rate
total across lifetime I guess, same value that the meter shows when you face it in person
The device has a local interface at port 80; default login is as follows:
Username: your CloudID (you’ll find it on the box and on the bottom of EAGLE-200 chassis)
Password: your Install Code (you’ll find it on the box and on the bottom of EAGLE-200 chassis)
Hardwired connection is required during initial setup, in order to access the web UI; through web UI you can connect it to Wifi, configure network settings, and disable remote access for Rainforest support. I haven’t tested, but it appears that this thing may be able to run completely locally, which is what I intend to pursue.
I did not register the device on Rainforest portal (because I don’t want unnecessary strangers having my usage data) but this also prevents me from receiving energy cost. A price I’m happy to pay.