I have 2 temperature sensors outside on different sides of my house. About half of the time the sun shines on one of them, and the other half it shines on the other. I want to have a sensor which shows the temperature from the one that do not have the sun shining on it. The timings of the sun I have, so that is sorted. Anyone know how to solve this?
I have the same, the easy way is to just use the lowest reading.
2 Likes
Thatās what I was going to suggest 
This is a classic! LOL
sigh
OK. I will solve this another way then.
Okay you want this the āhardā way.?
So you chose your flip-flop method of choosing sensors
(Iād go with sun azimuth (say) sun >= 76 or azimuth <= 256)
Then you have an āeastā is true
So : -
{{ states(āsensor.1ā) if east else states(āsensor.2ā) }}
Cast both to float if you need to (you shouldnāt need it)
Seriously, use the lower one. Create a template sensor that takes the minimum of the two real sensors and use that.
The Stevenson screen is also a good idea: I have a 3D-printed one for my single sensor. It almost eliminates the sun effect.
Aaah - Thatās not hard. Thanks.
You should post your resultant code to the thread and mark the post that helped you most as the solution.
But, to everyone else coming to this thread
The easy minimum of the two would have been : -
"{{ [ states('sensor.1') | float , states('sensor.2') | float ] | min }}"
The sensor (as duckboot wanted it, though he hasnāt specified his method of choosing, and ātimesā wonāt cut it as sun position is not reliable just on a time value) should finally end up something like : -
{% set azi = state_attr('sun.sun', 'azimuth') | float %}
{% set nrthwall = 26 %}
{% set sthwall = 206 %}
{% set temp1 = states('sensor.1') %}
{% set temp2 = states('sensor.2') %}
{% set east = nrthwall <= azi <= south %}
{{ temp1 if east else temp2 }}
I guess some peoples DIY skills arenāt upto building a screen, they donāt have somewhere to place it or the time involved just means its cheaper to buy another sensor
Uuuh - Toxic.
Well - I went down the Node-Red road and used node-red-contrib-sun-position and a compass for making my calculations. Pretty decent for a guy which āDIY skills arnāt upto building a screenā. (And the extra temp-sensors I did get for free, soā¦)
Sorry, you misunderstand, I was merely stating for general information why somebody would want to do as you did and not build a āspecial boxā
I did not intend to criticise you in any way merely explain possible motivations.
And who can resist free ?
No worries. I love it when internet-discussions go down the drain. After spending my professional and spare time on the internet since about 1994 Iām not easily offended in any way. Iāve probably seen and experienced it all. And agreed - Free is good. (I work at a company which have FOSS as a core value)
As an update, I now do this myself and hereās a plot showing how important it is:
Sensor 1 is on the east side of my garage, and is in a proper screen, yet still experiences significant over-reading in sunlight. Sensor 2 is on the west side of my garage in a black box to make it inconspicuous (this is the front of the house).
Yesterday was a sunny day, and you can see the effect on the east-facing sensor in the morning and the west-facing sensor in the afternoon. I take the minimum of the red and green plots as my combined outside temperature sensor.
1 Like