What Bulbs are you using (Ikea, Smart Life, Yeelight .....)?

Hi everyone,

I was wonderring what kind of Bulbs you use in your Home Assistant.
Currently I have a few Ikea Traadfri bulbs which does a very nice job considering the price.

But over the few days I’ve been looking in the Wish and Aliexpress App and I do see a lot of smart bulbs.
So I went back to the community and searched for some of the bulbs.
I can see that some people are struggling with the “Smart-Life Bulbs”.

I was hoping that I could add some bulbs that runs directly on wireless and then integrate them the same way as I do with my LED Controllers that runs the Flux_LED binding.

Have anyone any good suggestions?

I use GE link smart zwave/zigbee bulbs. Reasonable price, works with my Wink connected to HA without a hitch.

I’m using Osram Lightify (EU) and IKEA Tradfri through their gateways.

Both work very well, however, the Lightifys’ actual colours seem to be slightly off from what I select through Home Assistant. Also, you can’t use effects that you can select through the Lightify mobile app.

Tradfri, on the other hand, requires the remote to be used in addition to the gateway in order to make them accessible.

Currently, this is fine for me - I have the remote on my night table to switch the light directly. Should I find myself in the need of using just the bulbs for the majority of them, I’d probably try and go with a 3rd party gateway. Didn’t try to pair them with the Lightify gateway, yet.

When choosing between those two platforms, I’d rather go with Tradfri, as Osram integration seems to have more hiccups than Tradfri.

@Yoinkz I am assuming you are interested in WiFi-connected bulbs. Bulbs that connect with an app usually use a cloud-based service for the app. That means connecting with Home Assistant is indirect and requires an Internet connection to turn lights on and off. Your Ikea bulbs are connected locally. There may be WiFi bulbs that can be flashed with different firmware to eliminate the cloud-based service and make them local but then you become the direct support service should anything go wrong.
You will need to weigh the advantage of cost and advantage or disadvantage of local control. Local control, as in your Ikea bulbs, means instant response when you turn them on or off etc. As for lights, I personally don’t want the inherent delays of cloud-connected bulbs or switches.

Good solutions so far!

I agree, the advantage of the controller being local is preferable. I want the light to respond instant and not end up with a bulb that don’t want to turn on because of internet issues or a cloud service that is not responsible.

I was also looking at the MI light hub and its bulbs. I can see that there are different models e27 and GU10 etc.
That might be worth a shot?

Just about any dimmable bulbs + Lutron Caseta dimmers + a Lutron Caseta Pro Hub + Lutron Caseta Pro Component for Home Assistant = winning combination. It has simplified my setup.

I’m getting rid of all of my z-wave switches and zigbee bulbs.

Sounds interesting!

Can you link me the devices you listed?
Are they available on wish/ali/Amazon?

I have quite a lot of lamps but also different suppliers. Hassio makes global governance possible;)

I have a total of the following pears:
Hue (1x Bridge):
11 pieces (3x GU10 Color, 2x E14 White Ambiance, 1x Go, 3x E27 White & Color, 2x Living Colors)
2x Osram (Smart + Plug over the Hue Bridge)
Yeelight:
4 pieces (1x E27, 2x LED Stripe, 1x ceiling light)
IKEA TRÅDFRI (1x Bridge)
8x (6x GU10 White, 2x GU10 White Dimmable, controlled via the Hue Bridge)
1x wardrobe lighting (controlled by the IKEA Bridge)

In addition different sensors:
Hue:
5x motion detector
3x dimmer switch
TRÅDFRI:
1x motion detector
Xiamoi Aqara: (1x Gateway)
2x motion detector
7x door sensors
1x vibration sensor
2x temperature sensor
6x switch

I think I have not forgotten now :smiley:

With the help of the sensors and the automatisms I do not actually use a single light switch with me … Even the woman is thrilled;)

For last two years I used Philips Hue - a few E27, a bunch GU10 in kitchen and lately E14 in a shaded chandelier.

Recently wife granted me access to install E14 in a bunch of other lamps and went for Ikea TRADFRI ones due to the economics of it.

All above have worked great.

While doing that I also bought two IKEA E27 colored and those I’m not recommending - the colors/warmth is so weak compared to Philips Hue E27’s.

Oh and I’m this close of shutting down my Hue bridge as I install all new lights on a Conbee instead of hue and ikea bridge. Sometime next week i’ll just have one bridge and home assistant happily orchestrating it all.

2 Likes

Yikes :smile:… that sounds expensive - but a nice solution!
I would love to change all my GU10 bulbs to HUE, but 80 pieces would get kinda expensive :wink:

Sounds interesting. What is this conbee thing and what device is used (can you bring me up to speed here)?
Is it difficult to set up and configure?

see https://www.home-assistant.io/components/deconz/

basically I just bought the conbee usb stick from Dresden electronics, inserted it into my raspberry pi that runs hass.io - installed deconz hassio addon and off I went.

It requires some restarts or maybe just time sometimes when adding new devices but otherwise its working really well - my main usecase to get it is that with this bridge I get near instant notificiation of switches without constantly pulling the bridge.

Nice! Thank you…

May i know which model?

Hi Ener-G,

bit off topic but can you please describe your automation logic to make such that you don’t have to use switches?
I am sure you know in room presence (when rooms have multiple access and multiple people which could occupy them) is very hard!

Yes, sure. These are the NORRFLY light strips in combination with the TRÅDFRI driver.

The NORRFLY light bars actually have an integrated sensor, but I did not work as expected due to the cabinet construction with the sliding doors. So I solved that with two Xiaomi door sensors.

https://www.ikea.com/de/de/catalog/products/40332253/
https://www.ikea.com/de/de/catalog/products/60342656/

What I understand there is no european versions of Caseta

Hello, yes it’s not that easy, but not as difficult as you first suspect;)

It is important that you have time and always makes smaller optimizations … I have to publish my general configuration anyway on my ToDo list anyway but for this I have to optimize some things and document well.

Put simply, it is a mixture of motion detectors, device trackers, door sensors, light sensors, sun.

Example:
When there is movement in the bathroom, the light goes on. If there is no movement for 2 minutes, it will go off. But when the door is closed, the light does not go off automatically (our bathroom door is always open - unless someone is inside).

In the living room, individual spots automatically go on with sunset (or go on when someone comes home and the sun goes down).

In the hall pure motion detector for 2 minutes (a total of three motion detectors) and in addition a door sensor on the front door to make the first light the same a little brighter.

In the hobby room no motion detectors but coupled to different devices and calendar entries. When the TV is switched on, the TV lighting goes on. When certain football games are on and the TV is on, certain spots are on.

In the bedroom only on movement but only at certain times. The bed lighting (yeelight LED strip) is activated by pressing a button in the candlelight mode.
The wardrobe lighting with Xiaomi door sensors.

etc. etc.

In general, there are always different brightness levels, dimming levels, etc. depending on the current brightness, movement, time, sun, etc. The optimization of the logics never stops. There are always little things to improve or the woman has different requirements;)

Sorry for google translation

You know if they work with the Hue bridge?

I am not sure… sorry