So I used to use Fibaro Dimmers for my previous home, and well it worked for old style lamps. LEDs if it worked only with bypass.
So we moved into our new home, and all lamps are dimmed here - except they are not Z-Wave (or any other remotely controlled solution). However they are very flexible and can handle all lights even LEDs without any bypass, VADSBO LD220 for anyone who likes to google…
I need to replace them all, with dimmer that are Z-Wave controllable. I only need the dim function, and well it would be nice with energy consumption, however the only need I have is remote dimmable LEDs. Without any bypass.
Need to know your geo for any recommendation as power, radio and regulatory requirements differ.
That said, in my experience - it’s less about the switch and more about the bulb - especially if you have neutrals. I use a mix of GE/Jasco, Inovelli and Zooz devices. It took me about a week of trying a few different bulbs around the house before I found sets I was happy with (my Par38 can lights were the most difficult, ironically the no-name Home Depot brand ‘dimmable LEDs’ seemed to do the best here)
On that note, I’ve never had any issues with most of the generic brand lights as long as they were clearly marked ‘dimmable’ - the more expensive ones like the GE Reveal act up sometimes if the switch is at 100%.