HA lights sends true/false | native knx-devives send 1/0 | MDT

Configuration
,
1

Hi there,

I have a question/problem regarding the knx implementation.

I’ve got the following problem:
I have a light device defined in my configuration.yaml. The device can be controlled from the dashboard (on/off).

knx:
  light:
    - name: "Kitchen"
      address: "1/0/35"

My native knx-devices are from MDT.

Problem:

  • When I send the “on” command from the dashboard (HA), there will be emitted a true.
  • When I use a MDT push device there will be send a 1.
    Log
    Log1052×380 34.2 KB

Sometimes it does work, so the Switch Actuator will be set channel to “on”.

My question:
Can I overwrite the HA lights to send a 1/0? I think this is my problem in this case.

2

That’s technically the same.
Try to configure a state_address.

3

Hi,

the state_address is already set.

As you can see in the first post. A false will be sent and nothing happend to state. Here is a working example:

KNX_Works
KNX_Works1330×345 25.4 KB

This works sometimes, but not all the time. Therefore there must be a difference.

4

Try using ETS group monitor. This sounds like a connection or topology problem or something like that.