Thanks!!!
I have an AMX controller (that I’m looking to replace with HA). I unplugged that controller and now my lights and shades are working. my log now looks like this below.
I’m also not able to get the lights on one card like I see in HA demo screen for KNX. Rather I get this.
What are you referring to? Is this a frontend issue or has it to do with knx?
PS please put logs in code blocks (marked by backticks) or upload them to a code sharing site and just past the link here. Else information gets lost and it is unreadable.
Yosef, your posting really is a mess and you obviously didn’t even care to clean it up. But you still expect others to decifer it to help you. Sorry to be so blunt but I consider this disrespectful.
1 Like
Hi Matthias.
Thank for the assistance.
- FrontEnd - I figured out what I was doing wrong and I’m now using the Entity Card and I see the full list of lights.
- Log. HA is working fine. As I mentioned earlier - I’m replacing an AMX Controller that was the "brain’ - automation/control/macros for the KNX installation with HA.
Stuff that I’ve learned that might be helpful to others looking to get off AMX and have KNX continue to function.
-
If you have the .knxproj file - but don’t have ETS the script that I pasted earlier in this thread works great to pull out the address.
I have found that it only pulls out the one KNX address - not state move_short_address, stop_address. So I expect some pain with configuring dimmers, shutters and motion sensors. -
AMX controller and HA don’t play well together running at the same time. When AMX is connected, the HA cannot connect. When HA is connected - the AMX is not able to reach the KNX bus. It is probably because the Siemens KNX IP 148 1aB21 only accepts 1 concurrent connection.
-
My Mitsubishi HVAC is connected directly to an old Rs-232 Connection to AMX and then uses KNX to update the KNX Touchpads in every room. This is not going to be easy to connect to HA without spending money on a new IP based interface.
Apologies. Will be more careful in the future.
1 Like
It may help to use the HA KNX integration itself to log the traffic on the KNX bus. That way you would see all communication on the bus and can conclude the function of each group address. I have never done this as I have an ETS license. But @farmio explained it in this other thread:
Activate debug log for KNX - #2 by farmio
It can only extract group addresses that are configured. It is possible that some functions are just not liked to a group address. Also note that in the knx project itself there is no relation whatsoever between eg. brightness and brightness_state of a light etc. (except for very new projects using “Functions”).
The 2nd thing is just a shortcoming of the ip interface you are using. With one supporting multiple tunneling connections this should work just fine.
If KNX is not using functions that are linked to addresses - how can I control these from HA?
For example, I have dimmer lights that can be dimmed using the KNX switch - long Press. Or Blinds that a short press goes up or down a little bit, long press all the way down.
Thanks.
You can only interact with group addresses. If a communication object is not linked to one you can’t use it. But you could always get ETS and change this.
The light can’t be dimmed from HA if you don’t have a “dimming %” address (DPT 5).
The blinds should work. Your switch probably sends to different addresses on long/short.
Hello,
I have an Entities card from HA in which I select a date and time; I wanted to write the date and time in 2 GA. Is it possible ? This does not work :
configuration.yaml
# KNX
knx: !include_dir_merge_named knx/
knx_expose.yaml
expose:
- type: datetime
entity_id: input_datetime.heure_debut_chauffage
address: "4/7/0""
No. You can only send current (system time) date, time or datetime to the bus - just omit entity_id.
Thank you. This is bad news because I was thinking of using the Calendar module of my ABB ABA / S 1.2.1.
In addition, building this function with HA while keeping an interface that receives the start and end dates and times is not very easy.
Personally, I would not manage automations in two systems. Make HA your main automation engine and control all devices from there. KNX integration should be good enough to control any device connected to KNX bus. But I must admit that this ABB logic module was an over investment 
I prefer to keep ABA / S 1.2.1 which has advanced functions as the main automation engine because I believe it is more reliable than HA and the installation remains maintainable by an integrator KNX certified.
I want to use HA for supervision and some non-essential functions.
1 Like
Use the best tool for the job. I also don’t like to be bound to one system - this is not what knx is intended for.
You could try to create a value template forging the raw time payload to send it with knx.send which is probably doable, but a pita to set up.
Or you try if knx.send accepts it doesn’t.time as type - I have Never tried this, but it could theoretically work. It would require the time as a Python time.struct_time object then (again probably templating required).
I’m using a knx.sensor to track my called scene in my knx-network.
Sometimes the sensor does not update the scene send through the knx-system. After a hassio restart it usually works.
Any ideas?
Use always_callback = true on the sensor or try the knx scene platform.
Thats what i do too.
That was not clear by reading your configuration. 
You could also use a knx_event - this would be the HA preferred way, I think.
Sry
I just tried it and generally knx_event does work.
The problem is (and this might be the problem with the binary sensor as well), that only values that are read seem to get to the event bus.
What i mean is the following:
I do have the GroupAdress 0/0/1 for my scenes.
When i use the ETS GroupMonitor for testing purposes and send a scenenumber to my bus (write), nothing happens.
When i read the scenenumber (0/0/1) some of my knx-devices (that usually send a scene number) send a status on the bus (scenenumber 1). This fires an event and also show up in the binary sensor.
I have no clue what i am doing wrong. Any ideas?
Best regards,
Stefan