I could see the advantage of the Area, if we had the area as an attribute to the devices and its entities. I dont think we should ‘turn off everything’ in an Area, but I do want to be able to turn_off all motion sensors in an Area. Or all lights in an (nested) Area.
Example: Alarm system is on, all motion sensors and other motion triggers are on. Now, a guest enters the home, and I want to selectively dis-able the automation for the guest Area.
As it stands, I have several (not too complex) conditions in the trigger automations, but it would be way easier, if we could simple control that by turning off the motion sensors in the Area?
If had FR about the attributes, but that seems to have gotten no attention here, so guess nobody agrees with me on the subject
About the GUI: I don’t use that, because it cant handle my automations (or kills the annotations) so it should be manually doable. Havent seen a way to handle Areas in automations at all tbh.
Btw, the fact we can’t have nested Areas hampers the functionality hugely. Right now I would have to create either 1 Area for my living room, but then this would act on my dining corner, audio setup, Den and ceiling spots… to name but a few smart devices in the Living.
If I’d go the other way, and create Areas for these selected smaller groups in the Living, Id be back where we are now, not being able to act upon them in a grouped way and only target several devices in that larger Area…
I wonder what ‘they’ were thinking when Architecting the Area concept in HA. 1 room Home’s? 4 light rooms?
Must confess I have been searching the docs, but this is the only thing I could find: https://www.home-assistant.io/integrations/config/#areas ?