Isn’t that strange that the people want it is not implemented.
Only new feature that almost nobody uses.
I have used Homeseer many years and got tired of it.
Homeassistant has made automation fun again.
Homeseer has grouping of automation and i am missing it.
Now i have to make several rows of autmation that is hard to overview.
Probably only looking for the perfect month on the release plan to roll out this feature. Currently it looks like tags are going to make it (“disabled” is a tag). Let’s see when it arrives.
folder and tags would useful, add tags to the automation as an automation could have several tags, but then be able able to organise in your own folder structure
I would be up for color coding at least, I made a mockup in photoshop of what i think it could look like. It’s also not a big departure from what’s currently in place. Colors would be a visual cue to the user that they are looking at a different ‘chunk’ of automations. I think this would be east to implement also
Probably stating the obvious and knocking in open doors, but yes, I would love to see 5he possibility to create folders, like “Lighting”, “Car charging”, “Presence Control” or similar.
I come from a Homey home controller and it have many many drawbacks in comparison, but one really good thing with my Homey was to organize all my different flows (automations) in different folders.
Group tags and stuff are nice and all that, but it doesn’t help to get s cleaner overview, I guess.
Please, just do it.
if you want a workaround for the grouping problem, try my custom panel which displays automations in a tree view. To create the tree, I use the name from the automation like Floor // Room // Automation.
I second this proposal also, really good idea. The same goes for Helpers, I guess, and Scenes, Scripts, Blueprints. We have (almost) the same principle in Lovelace these days, in the form of subviews. So it’s like upping some other views to the same standard
I had a similar problem and automated this through pyscript (Python code). It was somehow better organized but it was code and I lost the visual aspect.
I am now trying to go for Automations (the ones in the UI) but this has the drawback you described.
A tree instead of a flat list would solve the issue immediately
In HA 2021.4 some improvements were made to automation organization, and it seems like the Home Assistant maintainers now considers this feature request implemented (see Github discussion).
In my opinion the changes added in HA 2021.4 are a good start but not nearly sufficient. The problem is that this feature request is no longer considered by the maintainers because it predates the implemented solution.
Creating a new feature request that highlights the problems with the filters as of 2023, and proposes specific improvements might be more effective. That way this will once again be on the maintainer’s radar.
I apologize in advance for the poor text. He was translated by Google…
I think that the current view of the list of automations is quite convenient, except for some problems. The biggest problem is finding and structuring automations. The developers have already added several features to filter automations by spaces, devices, and objects. This helps to some extent but is still not universal and creates confusion when looking for the right automations. Why is that? It seems to me because everyone creates and groups automations according to their own logic. I think in this case the best solution would be to simply add a TAG field to the automation edit page. You can add as many tags as you want to the field, for example - #gps, #telegram, #phones. And already during the search, it will be possible to set the search for one or more tags. In the future, you can improve this functionality by adding a different line color for each tag or a picture, etc.