🔥 Advanced Heating Control

[mukrop (Martin Ukrop)]

Oh god, this thread is running so fast :D.

Reportingmore details on my issued with Danfoss Ally.

1. Seeing your logic – now I see my interpration of the events was wrong. You’re indeed not setting anything periodically. The thing is that Danfoss uses the -8000 (“-80.00°C”) as an undefined/unused value. So if the temperature does not get update by automation in due interval (180/30 minutes), e.g due to differences smaller than the delta, the TRV turns the feature off setting the externally set temperature to -8000. Then, the automation sees the difference larger than delta and sets it back in a few minutes.
   When I set the delta to 0, the situation practically resolves (unless the precise temperature would hold for 180/30 minutes, which could borderline happen… but well good enough now).
   The TRV documentation is almost fully available at ZigBee2MQTT, specifically here. Note the info on the need to be setting things periodically.

2. However, I still have the problem that only one of the two TRVs has the temperature set by the automation at all. I’ve reliably tested that it’s always the second of the two listed in the automation configuration.
   Any idea what may be wrong there? Can I help you with any debug trace?

[allard77 (Allard K)]

@panhans

Maybe there is an exisisting implementation out there?!

Look for the posts by le_top here Danfoss Ally TRV working with remote temp sensor - #160 by le_top for a lot of info

[stephanschleichstr13]

I will test these the next days again and give feedback. a special Service for the temp is not necessary

One question: can you set the hvac mode as a pulldown (currently he goes directly to mode “heat”), when this is manuell settable i can use your blueprint as air conditioner “heat/cool/dry” too, this would be great.

[panhans]

@mukrop @allard77 Thank you for the information.

I just did an update for v4. Popp / Hive / Danfoss calibration gets triggered every 30 minutes (Maybe we make this adjustable) and when automation gets reloaded or after a home assistant restart.

I think traces wouldn’t help in some situations no more because I move much logic to jinja code. But it’s also easier for me to debug.

I just saw that I did a mistake in calibration logic for Danfoss/Popp/Hive. Just pull the new version and give it another try.

If it also won’t work for you I will provide some jinja code that can be pasted into the template editor.

Thanks!

[tirol3]

my temp config is not working . i used beta version it was working.
time is now 11:16 temp is now 23

[panhans]

Sorry for that inconvenience.

1. All values need to be in quotation marks
2. atm the day filter just allows one weekday (will expand this soon)

e.g.

- time: "18:00"
  day: "Sun"
  temp: "21"

//EDIT: also fixed the example in the description. Sry again

[tirol3]

can we use like this ?

• time: “07:00”
  temp: “23”
• time: “09:00”
  temp: “21”
• time: “17:00”
  temp: “22”
• time: “18:00”
  temp: “23”
• time: “00:00”
  temp: “15”

[tirol3]

you can use for this scheulder for temp planing. exampler

morning sch. : 23
day sch : 21
evening sch : 23
night sch : 15

[panhans]

@tirol3

• time: “07:00”
  temp: “23”
• time: “09:00”
  temp: “21”
• time: “17:00”
  temp: “22”
• time: “18:00”
  temp: “23”
• time: “00:00”
  temp: “15”

Yes, but I also want to differ between minimum and comfort temp in future.

@tirol3

morning sch. : 23
day sch : 21
evening sch : 23
night sch : 15

Yes, a filter for scheduler is also planed.

I am not that fast and just want to provide a first stable implementation to build on.

[tirol3]

thanks we are waiting, using and testing.

[tirol3]

if windows open temo si changing every sec

[panhans]

Do you use another integration? Temperature changes will be blocked when thermostats set to off.

Just enable debugging for the blueprint and check your logs and search for “changes”.

Changes should only filled when window is opened and after it got closed.

[bandit79]

First off all, the blueprint is great. I use it for several weeks or month and it works perfect till the last update.

I have the same issue when window is opened, the TRV mode switches from off the heat and reverse. Also the days in the heating plan won’t saved in quotes. If i use quotes, they’re gone after saving.

[panhans]

@bandit79

I have the same issue when window is opened, the TRV mode switches from off the heat and reverse.

Thanks for reporting. I try to recreate that issue. I think it has something to do with that adjustment feature. Will check this!

@bandit79

Also the days in the heating plan won’t saved in quotes. If i use quotes, they’re gone after saving.

This bad is that this it must formatted strictly.
This for example works for me:

- time: "09:49"
  temp: "22"
- time: "11:27"
  temp: "24"
  day: "Mo"
- time: "20:11"
  temp: "25"

//EDIT: cannot recreate that window open issue. Could you provide a trace log when window is open and the temperature kicks in?

[bandit79]

I will try the format. Do i have to use only 2 letters for the day like in your example an is it possible to concat the weekdays like

- time: "11:27"
  temp: "24"
  day: "Mon,Tue,Wed,Thu,Fri"

[tirol3]

only windows open have a problem. i am using one integration

[panhans]

Have a look here. Atm this is not possible.

[bandit79]

I’m sorry, i missed this reply

[panhans]

No problem. I found the issue with the temperature. Will fix it soon.

[tirol3]

my old config is here for beta . is it true or i must delete it.